EN - US
English Portuguese (BR)
For employers

How to Assess Candidates for Team Fit and Skills

Strider Staff November 15, 2024
Assessing candidate fit

Hiring the right developer is crucial for a company's success, especially as technology becomes central to all aspects of business. For employers, the hiring process isn't just about filling a position: it's about finding a skilled professional who aligns with your company's vision and can effectively contribute to your projects.

In this guide, we'll explore how to assess candidates thoroughly, from evaluating technical skills to understanding past performance, to help you identify the best fit for your team and objectives.

Understanding the Importance of Assessing Candidates

Assessing candidates thoroughly, especially developers, is essential to ensure they bring the right mix of skills to your team.

A comprehensive assessment allows you to evaluate hard and soft skills, confirming that the candidate has the technical expertise needed for your projects while fitting into your company's culture and collaborating effectively with team members.

While a developer's portfolio can provide insight into their previous projects and areas of expertise, it only offers a partial view. A deeper dive into their technical and behavioral capabilities gives hiring managers a more accurate picture of the candidate's potential fit.

Evaluating Technical Skills

Evaluating technical skills is essential when assessing candidates, and there are several effective ways to do it. 

While senior developers are expected to maintain a high standard of code quality, hiring managers often look beyond pure coding skills to assess additional abilities, such as effective communication, leveraging team strengths, and troubleshooting complex issues.

Based on our experience at Strider, we advise against live-coding interviews for senior developers because they limit each candidate's potential and problem-solving skills. 

Alternatively, take-home assignments allow candidates to showcase their abilities more naturally, using resources and techniques they've built up over their career

Another approach is to conduct live interviews focusing on real-world applications of their skills, inviting candidates to discuss past projects and how they navigated challenges.

Analyzing the Curriculum and Portfolio

Examining a candidate's resume and portfolio helps validate their experience and relevance to the position. Make sure the projects in their portfolio align with the job requirements—or, if relevant projects aren't present, ensure they have certifications or training that demonstrate proficiency in the specific languages, frameworks, or applications needed.

During the interview, you can dig deeper to understand their level of understanding of the specific topic required for the position they are applying to. 

Look for diversity in the types of technologies, challenges, and project scopes they've handled. A strong portfolio will showcase various skills, from tackling multiple technical problems to serving different user bases, which speaks to the candidate's adaptability and breadth of experience.

Reviewing Past Work

A developer's past work offers invaluable insights into their reliability, skills, and commitment to ongoing improvement. When reviewing their portfolio, look for the following:

  • Project Completion: are there any incomplete projects? If so, consider asking why they were not finished.
  • Portfolio Freshness: is their portfolio up-to-date? A lack of recent projects might indicate their skills haven't evolved with the latest industry standards.
  • Impact Metrics: can they provide metrics, KPIs, or other data to show the impact of their past contributions? Quantifiable results demonstrate the real value they brought to previous teams and help you gauge their potential contributions to your company.

Assessing Soft Skills

Setup to assess candidate skill during interview

Technical skills alone don't define a top-tier developer.

While expertise is essential, soft skills allow developers to grow and collaborate successfully in a team setting. Communication, teamwork, and adaptability are all crucial elements for developers, especially those at senior levels, enabling them to support and inspire their colleagues and navigate complex projects successfully.

Communication Skills

Effective communication is a hallmark of top developers. The best candidates can interact confidently and clearly with different parties involved in the software development lifecycle, including final clients and other stakeholders.

Strong communicators also excel in remote or asynchronous settings. This is especially important in today's work environment, where remote collaboration is common and clear, and efficient communication is essential to keep projects on track.

Teamwork and Collaboration

The ability to collaborate effectively in remote or distributed teams has become a fundamental skill for tech professionals. During the candidate assessment process, look for examples of past experience working with remote teams and the ability to manage collaboration in virtual settings.

Consider conducting mock scenarios or situational role-plays that simulate critical situations a developer might face. This approach can reveal how they interact under pressure, showing whether they remain a positive influence during challenging moments.

As a result, you'll have a clearer insight into assessing whether they will be constructive team players.

Problem-Solving and Adaptability

Software development is rarely straightforward, and unanticipated changes can disrupt schedules or introduce new complexities.

A strong developer will demonstrate resilience and adaptability, knowing how to adjust to new requirements or challenges as they arise.

This skill goes beyond understanding client requests: it involves identifying essential requirements and incorporating them seamlessly into the project timeline.

A candidate with solid problem-solving abilities and flexibility will help the team stay agile and maintain project momentum despite unexpected obstacles.

Determining Cultural Fit

Technical skills and effective collaboration are essential, but a candidate's alignment with the company's core values is equally crucial. Cultural fit ensures that new hires share the company's mission and vision, fostering a more engaged and productive workforce.

When employees feel aligned with their organization's values, they're more likely to be committed to their work and contribute positively to the team environment.

Each company has unique values, but technology teams often look for qualities such as a willingness to collaborate, respect for diverse perspectives, eagerness to learn and improve, and a commitment to teamwork.

These qualities promote a healthy work culture and enhance the team's collective ability to solve complex challenges.

Final Steps in Assessing Candidates

As you wrap up the assessment process, keep in mind the key takeaways to guide your final hiring decision:

Balance Technical and Soft Skills

While technical expertise is vital, the best developers bring well-rounded skills, including communication, teamwork, and problem-solving abilities. Review portfolios thoroughly, but remember they are only part of the picture.

Evaluate Cultural Fit

Soft skills and cultural alignment are equally important in identifying candidates who will thrive within your team's dynamic and contribute to your company's core values.

Use Available Resources

Take advantage of specialized platforms to make assessing hard and soft skills easier. Combining the technical assessment with in-depth interviews offers valuable insights into a candidate's interpersonal abilities, communication style, and problem-solving skills.

By following these guidelines for assessing candidates, you can make a more informed decision and hire a skilled developer who will be a great long-term addition to your team.

Strider simplifies your recruitment process. Just provide us with your job requirements, and we'll match your needs with thousands of vetted software developers in our database.

Get the top talent you need to drive your growth. Choose your tech stack and discover how Strider can support you!

Recommended for you

For employers

The Pros and Cons of Different Employment Types

Strider Staff
For employers

Creating an Effective Onboarding Program

Strider Staff
For employers

How to Hire Remote Developers

Strider Staff